200105對話

關於 HANA-BI
hana-bi? u watched? that is my favorite movie.my question is about the illustrations in the movie n the charactor called 堀部, why he choose flower?...represence of happiness. a short one. also can be no reason... art got no reason.my opinion is " qin qing" .親情?
ya. becoz one of his pic shown tat a family is "shang hua". and we always send flower to whom we care, and the angel at the begining, i think it's represent his wife.
my way of thinking is he recovered from depression, he didn't suicide.he didn't suicide? the flower is about 堀部, the angel is about the main charactor.i dont think u should relate two of them in the art.no, i think it's relate. the pic of 堀部 is relate to the journey of the main charactor.no. they are parellel but not the same,though they may talking about the same thing.good point!!the parellel one is the view of life. the same thing talk about is LOVE.
yes, i agree.堀部 found LOVE in life again, 西 loving wat he has.
堀部 found..again..? u mean painting?
he didnt suiside himself, but express it through his paintings.
but 西 has suiside?
yes, together with his love one.ya. do u think it's his way to treasure his love?
dead or not is not the main thing,is what they have found--LOVE. dead here in the end is not negative but positive. when he still has his choice, he still choose to love together n die together. though seems that he has no choise. but i think it is also a good choice he made. coz he robe.
y..?堀部 think of suiside?
ya, as he immobilize, his family left him alone.
ya.. he lost his 寄托, so he fell sad.
是, 原本看似屬於他的東西, 突然因為殘廢而離開了他.
ya, he think of suiside, rite? but y he didn't.
是.
他雖然想的和主角一樣, 但采取的行動不一樣? 意味這他選擇留下, 選擇畫畫為寄托?...
你想說什么?
最後堀部感受到西的關懷, 重拾自己的生活, 對生命的熱愛, 感動. 然而, 西, 他自從同事生亡後, 意識到生命的可貴, 加上自己太太的絕症, 更意識到生命的可貴, 以及無價... 友情,愛情,親情... 雖然, 堀部的家人離開他, 西並沒有因為這樣而怪罪任何人... 或許, 因為愛是單方面的付出... 西對堀部的關心也是如此. 真誠的付出.
你認為西是好人. 即使他打劫銀行也是為了補償他身邊的人? 有一點我觀察不出, 他什么時候退出警隊的?
他沒有退出警隊, 他知道他有責任. 可是, 他選擇了那樣面對他的人生... 或許, 對他來說,陪著愛人渡過這一生是最重要的是吧.
為何喜歡這部片?很喜歡, 感人, 哭. 如果是我, 我也會那麼做.
西的角色一直是盡力安慰他身邊的人.我覺得蠻多時後我也如此.
哈哈! 他的部下是來逮捕他的吧? 可是之前也有說到他們心目中的西. 說他后來變得血腥, 他不選擇殺害他的部下, 于是他殺了自己. 可是有一點... 我不認為主角的肢体語言演得很好... 他沒甚麼表情啊.
那是因為他是警察. 鐵面的警察...

p/s: special thankx to PL